Does a Room Have to Have a Closet to be Considered a Bedroom?
We have had these questions asked of us: Do I have a 4 bedroom home or a 3 bedroom home? Does a bedroom have to have a closet to be considered to be a bedroom? Does a bedroom have to have a window? What are the requirements for a room to be considered a bedroom?
Taking a Look at Guidelines and Regulations:
First, we will look at what guidelines and regulations have to say about bedrooms.
*FNMA (Fannie Mae) guidelines which apply to most appraisals on residential properties for mortgage lending states:
The Appraiser must not identify a room as a bedroom that cannot accommodate ingress or egress in the event of an emergency, regardless of location above or below grade
( FNMA 4000.1 Guidelines)
( FNMA 4000.1 Guidelines)
There is nothing in FNMA guidelines stating the need for a closet, but that there needs to be ingress or egress in the event of an emergency. The methods of ingress or egress in the event of an emergency is typically in the form of a window but may also be a door.
*International Residential Code:which creates minimum regulations for one and two-family dwellings of three stories or less, has the following requirements for bedrooms:
The provisions in Section R310.1 of the International Residential Code require basements and sleeping rooms to be provided with emergency escape and rescue openings. When the construction of additions and alterations change the use of the existing basement, emergency escape and rescue openings must be provided; regardless of the requirements in place when the dwelling was originally constructed. (IRC)
For rooms with sloped ceilings, at least 50 percent of the required floor area of the room shall have a ceiling height of at least 7 feet (2134 mm) and no portion of the required floor area may have a ceiling height of less than 5 feet (1524 mm) (IRC)
R304.2 Other rooms. Other habitable rooms shall have a floor area of not less than 70 square feet (6.5 m2). Exception: Kitchen
R304.3 Minimum dimensions. Habitable rooms shall not be less than 7 feet (2134 mm) in any horizontal dimension. Exception: Kitchens. (IRC)
Based on the International Residential Code, bedrooms need an emergency escape or rescue opening (ingress and egress), need to have at least 50% of the ceiling at least 7 feet, and be at minimum of 70 square feet. The IRC does not address the need for a closet for a bedroom.
*Local City and County Codes- city and county may differ from these codes and should be considered in a local market.
How Appraisers Look at Bedrooms:
Along with considering the guidelines and regulations, appraisers look at markets and how different features respond to market participants. Appraisers will determine what is accepted in a certain market as not all markets are the same.
Is a property located in a residential neighborhood or development where all bedrooms have closets? This market will expect bedrooms to have a closet. Buyers in this market would most likely not consider a room without a closet a bedroom. If, however, a property is located in an older neighborhood with older homes which were typically not built with closets in the bedroom, then buyers would most likely consider a room without a closet a bedroom as they are more common for that neighborhood.
Is a property located in a residential neighborhood or development where all bedrooms have closets? This market will expect bedrooms to have a closet. Buyers in this market would most likely not consider a room without a closet a bedroom. If, however, a property is located in an older neighborhood with older homes which were typically not built with closets in the bedroom, then buyers would most likely consider a room without a closet a bedroom as they are more common for that neighborhood.
Conclusions:
For a room to be considered a bedroom it must have:
1. Emergency egress & ingress ( typically a window but may also be a second door)
2. Ceiling Height of 7 feet for 50% of the ceiling and no less than 5 feet.
3. Minimum of 70 square feet
4, Closet- It will depend on the market. Technically bedrooms do not need a closet, however in many markets closets in bedrooms would be expected and rooms without closets would not be considered bedrooms. Older neighborhoods where homes were not originally built with closets would be the exception.
We hope this helped explain the requirements of a bedroom and you can now rest easy at night. If you have any additional questions or comments feel free to contact us at www.dwslaterco.com or comment on this blog. You can subscribe to this blog by adding your email at the top right corner.
Additional Resources and Reads:
The 4 requirements for a room to be considered a bedroom- Sacramento Appraisal Blob, Ryan Lundquist
When is a bedroom NOT a bedroom?- Birmingham Appraisal Blog, Tom Horn
When is a bedroom NOT a bedroom?- Birmingham Appraisal Blog, Tom Horn
Does a Bedroom Need a Closet to Appraise? - The Balance, Elizabeth Weintraub
Nice job. This is a very important question. Thanks for the link to my article also. I appreciate it.
ReplyDeleteThanks Ryan, we get this question ever so often so I thought it would be good to address on our blog. Thanks for your comments. They are always appreciated.
DeleteGreat article Shannon. This is one of the top questions I get and it can be confusing to agents who may want to list a room as a bedroom for marketing purposes. If they list it as one but then the appraiser does not call it a bedroom this can cause potential problems. You've given some useful info. here for agents and owners and thanks for the mention.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Tom. I agree that it can be confusing for agents and homeowners which is why it is good to get the information out there. Thanks for your comments and for your terrific blog!
Delete